China H1N1 Strategy Was Superior

by


China has had far fewer deaths from H1N1 and has limited and delayed the spread of H1N1.

From April 25 to July 5, a total of 8,272 people entering China with flu-like symptoms were transferred to medical institutions for quarantine. Some 228 of them were confirmed as H1N1 flu patients.

China’s strategy for fighting swine-flu is “resource intensive.” But China’s strategy worked to greatly slow the spread of swine flu infections in their country; Australia’s strategy didn’t do the same for their country. China’s way of fighting the pandemic was to greatly limit its spread at the start. That doesn’t mean they caught every case. It means they caught every case that came to the attention of a physician or hospital. The CDC pandemic-fighting model is based largely on analysis of the 1918 swine flu pandemic. China’s model is based on empirical observations of the way ‘airborne’ or aerosolized infectious disease first spreads from country to country in the 21st Century; namely, via globalized, heavy-volume commercial airline travel. There is no way to erase the data on China’s success at doing the Number One thing a national pandemic fighting plan is supposed to do: greatly slow the spread of the disease in a country.

Report from the summer of 2009 on the H1N1 procedures:
When the plane lands, current procedure is that four medical personnel come on board and check everyone’s temperature with a very fast “ear” thermometer. We were on a smaller plane and waited in total about 35 minutes until they were finished and cleared the plane so that we could all leave.

China has far fewer cases relative to India, Australia, and the United States. The United States now.

India’s H1N1 Situation

India has had 351 dead from H1N1 as of Oct 11, 2009, but china only had their second H1N1 death on October 18, 2009

China had ignored the World Health Organization recommendation to not test for H1N1 and not try to institute quarantine of sick inbound travellers.

CDC guidelines were for separating people with 6 feet or more distance but not putting them into mandatory isolation.

27 page document that discussed the options for managing H1N1. At the end of it:

In the face of the current situation of the new influenza A(H1N1), WHO does not currently recommend international border closures or international
travel restrictions.